VFD, PLC, or Backup Generator? A Procurement Guide for Facility Power Decisions
Posted 2026-10-30 by Mateo Alvarez
I'm the office administrator for a 180-person manufacturing company. I handle the ordering for facilities and maintenance—roughly $400,000 annually across about 30 vendors, depending on whether you count the one-off purchases. I report to both operations and finance, which means every purchase has to survive two different kinds of scrutiny.
Six years into this job, I've learned that "we need better power" is not a purchasing instruction. It's a starting point for about five different conversations. Depending on who's asking—maintenance, IT, or the plant manager—it could mean motor control, backup power, automation, or all three at once.
So before you start collecting quotes, figure out which problem you actually have. Here's how I'd break it down.
The three scenarios (and they don't overlap as much as you'd think)
The requests I've handled fall into roughly three buckets:
- Scenario A: You have motors, pumps, or fans that run at fixed speed and either waste energy or keep tripping breakers. You likely need a variable frequency drive (VFD).
- Scenario B: You have processes that need to run in a specific sequence or react to sensor input. You need PLC logic programming.
- Scenario C: You need power to keep running when the grid goes down. You need a generator, and then a safety decision about how it connects to your building.
These overlap in practice—a facility with VFDs probably also has a PLC controlling them. But the purchase and the questions you ask are different, so I'll handle them separately.
Scenario A: You need a VFD (likely Danfoss)
If maintenance says "the motor keeps tripping on overload" or "we're burning through belts," you're probably looking at a VFD. For most of our applications, the spec lands on a Danfoss VFD—the VLT FC 102 is common for HVAC, and the FC 302 shows up on more demanding setups.
Here's what I got wrong the first time: I treated the VFD as the whole purchase. It's not. The drive itself is maybe 60% of the total. You also need line reactors, fuses, a disconnect, and often a bypass panel if you want the motor to run without the drive.
Looking back, I should have asked for a "commissioning-included" quote. At the time, I thought installation was installation. It's not. Programming the drive to match your motor nameplate is a separate line item, and nobody mentions it until the drive is on the wall.
A note on that Danfoss VFD motor ETR over A10 fault you might have seen scroll past your inbox: A10 is the drive telling you the electronic thermal relay tripped—basically, it thinks the motor is overheating. Most of the time it's a parameter mismatch (motor current set too low for the actual motor) rather than a real failure. It's fixable, but it gets logged as "VFD failure" in your maintenance system when it isn't one. Worth knowing before you replace a perfectly good drive.
Two questions to ask before you sign anything:
- Does the quote include parameter setup for our specific motor nameplate?
- What's the lead time on a replacement drive if one fails?
We've ordered maybe 14 drives in the past year—maybe 12, I'd have to check the system. Lead times ranged from three days to six weeks depending on the model. If I remember correctly, the FC 102 smaller-frame units were the fastest. That range matters more than the sticker price when a pump goes down on a Friday.
Scenario B: You need PLC logic programming
This is the scenario where the equipment is fine but the control isn't. If operators are physically flipping switches in a sequence, or if a process depends on someone remembering to do X after Y, you're a PLC candidate.
I'll be honest: this is the scenario I'm least qualified to spec. I rely on our controls contractor for the details. But from the purchasing side, I've learned three things:
- Programming hours are the variable. Two quotes for "the same" PLC job can differ by 40% because one contractor estimates 20 hours of logic design and the other estimates 60.
- Ask for the I/O list. How many inputs and outputs? If the vendor won't provide a list upfront, you're going to be surprised by change orders.
- Documentation is part of the deal. You want the ladder logic and a written sequence of operation. If they won't hand it over, walk.
One regret I still carry: I didn't specify who owns the PLC code. When the contractor left, we had the hardware but not the logic—and no way to modify it without calling them back at their hourly rate. If I could redo it, I'd put code ownership and documentation in the spec. But given what I knew then—nothing about the fine print—my choice was reasonable at the time.
Scenario C: You need backup power
This is where "whole house generator prices" questions land, though in a commercial setting it's really "what does it cost to keep operations running during an outage."
The price question is nearly impossible to answer generically because it depends on load. In our area, a commercial standby generator sized for office lighting and IT loads quoted in the low five figures. A generator sized to run a production line was closer to six figures. Those aren't the same product with a different markup—they're different machines.
The decision that actually matters for procurement is generator interlock vs transfer switch, and here's the thing most quotes won't tell you: they aren't really competitors. They're solutions to different-sized problems.
Generator interlock
An interlock is a mechanical kit that prevents your main breaker and generator breaker from being on at the same time. It's cheap—a few hundred dollars for the hardware—and it relies on a human physically flipping breakers in the right order. That's fine for a small shop with one maintenance person who knows the procedure. It's a liability in a building with shift turnover and multiple people who might touch the panel.
Automatic transfer switch (ATS)
An ATS does the same thing automatically: it senses grid loss, starts the generator, transfers the load, and reverses the process when the grid returns. It costs more—commonly in the $1,500 to $5,000 range for the switch itself before installation—and it's essentially required if you want the building to keep running without anyone on site.
Here's the counterintuitive part, at least to me: the cost of the transfer switch is sometimes the argument for the generator, not against it. If you're buying backup power because you want reliability, then "nobody has to come in at 2 a.m. to flip a breaker" is the actual value. An interlock can defeat that. You've bought the generator but not the reliability—and you find out during the first outage.
Per NFPA 70 (the National Electrical Code), Article 702 covers optional standby systems, and a listed transfer switch is the standard way to prevent backfeeding the utility. An interlock is legal when listed and installed correctly—but "installed correctly" is doing a lot of work in that sentence, and I've learned to verify it.
So which scenario are you actually in?
Ask what the request is really answering:
- If the complaint is energy bills or tripped breakers, you're in Scenario A. Start with a VFD quote that includes commissioning in the total.
- If the complaint is operators doing things in the wrong order, you're in Scenario B. Start with an I/O list and a clear conversation about who owns the code.
- If the complaint is "we lose power and lose production," you're in Scenario C. Size the load first, then choose interlock vs ATS based on whether anyone will actually be on site when the lights go out.
And if you're answering "all three"—welcome to my last six months. Do them in order: VFDs first (they often reduce the load the generator has to carry), PLC next (it makes the equipment behave predictably), generator last (it's the most expensive and the easiest to oversize).
The one rule I'd hand to any procurement person facing this: ask what's not included before you ask what the price is. The vendor who lists setup fees, commissioning costs, and code-ownership terms upfront—even if the total looks higher—usually costs less by the time you're done. (note to self: put that sentence into the new vendor evaluation template by Friday.)
